James Cameron’s Titanic came out in theaters on December 19, 1997. It made billions of dollars at the box office. It was released on VHS in September 1998 and DVD in August 1999. For nearly three decades it’s been one of the most enduring pieces of popular culture, based on one of the most famous events in history. For 26 years it’s been referenced, parodied, celebrated and rewatched. It’s hard to believe there’s a way to talk about this movie that hasn’t already been covered.
And yet Joe Buck may have done it.
On Friday afternoon Buck was watching Titanic, as most people are wont to do. Near the end of the film, while Buck sat in a chair next to his neatly made bed, the former longtime voice of the World Series and current voice of ESPN’s Monday Night Football, posted a video to his X / Twitter account pointing out a continuity error.
It turns out Buck really doesn’t like how James Cameron sunk that boat and he could no longer keep it inside. So he made a video explaining his issues with the way this famous scene was shot. He did this while recording his television from across the room. Buck is completely off camera. Except for his feet.
Here’s an opportunity twitter – sorry, X – to tell me again that I’m stupid. Please, I’m begging you pic.twitter.com/z1iMP7Ck9J
— Joe Buck (@Buck) May 31, 2024
“This shot doesn’t make any sense,” Buck says. “It’s going in and now it’s flat? Now you see the back of the ship. Going… There’s no continuity there. This thing is going in nose down. The Titanic piece that is written there—hould be up in the air. Going in. This way. Instead all of a sudden it goes this way? What? It’s always bothered me. One more time. It’s going in vertically. K? The back of the ship’s in the air. So if you’re going to have the writing of the Titanic—it can’t be that way! Now it’s flat into the water? Now watch, it’s going to be flat again… with the back. No! That would have been pointed up the other way. It would have been pointed away. Terrible.”
We are not here to litigate the movie Titanic, which made $2.2 billion dollars in theaters on a budget of $200 million and was the highest grossing movie of all-time until Cameron released Avatar more than a decade later.
What we are here to litigate is the gratuitous shots of Joe Buck’s feet in this video. Do you know how distracting something has to be to take people’s eyes of Kate and Leo here? His toes have more screen time than Bill Paxton. If you were ever looking for an argument against vertical video, this is it.
Football season can’t come soon enough. We need Buck and his bare feet grinding game tape, not crushing plot holes.
At the very least we need socks.
